🤔 US-UK Trade Deal: Northern Ireland

Commons Chamber

🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️

The UK and US have reached a new trade deal that aims to benefit the entire UK, including Northern Ireland, by saving jobs and boosting sectors like automotive, steel, and pharmaceuticals. Secretary of State Jonathan Reynolds emphasized the deal’s importance, noting that it maintains high food standards and sanitary regulations, despite concerns about its complexity and impact on Northern Ireland due to the Windsor Framework. Northern Ireland’s businesses and consumers face challenges with EU tariffs and a complicated duty reimbursement system, which the government is committed to improving. The agreement is seen as a starting point for deeper trade relations with the US, amidst ongoing discussions about its specific impacts and the need for better parliamentary scrutiny.

Summary

  • The UK and US have reached a trade deal that impacts Northern Ireland specifically due to its unique position under the Windsor Framework.
  • Northern Ireland exporters will have the same preferential access to the US market as the rest of the UK, as it is part of the UK’s customs territory and internal market.
  • US origin goods entering Northern Ireland will not face additional duties if they are not at risk of entering the EU, thanks to schemes like the UK internal market scheme.
  • A tariff reimbursement scheme is available for Northern Ireland businesses to claim back the difference between UK and EU duties if goods do not enter the EU market.
  • The deal aims to save thousands of jobs and provide the UK with a trade advantage over other countries with the US.
  • Key sectors benefiting include automotive (with reduced tariffs on a quota of vehicles), steel and aluminium (with 25% tariffs removed), pharmaceuticals and life sciences (with preferential access if new US tariffs arise), and aerospace (with zero tariffs on exports).
  • The deal includes agreements on US beef, ethanol, and economic security, with specific quotas and duty-free allowances.
  • Concerns were raised about the complexity and bureaucratic burden of the tariff reimbursement system, especially for Northern Ireland businesses.
  • The government emphasized its commitment to work with Northern Ireland stakeholders to address these concerns and improve the system’s efficiency.
  • The trade deal is part of broader efforts to strengthen UK trade relations globally, following a recent deal with India.

Divisiveness

The rating of disagreement displayed in the session is a 2 out of 5 because while there are instances of disagreement and criticisms, they are generally expressed in a moderate and constructive manner. The disagreements mainly revolve around the impact of the US-UK trade deal on Northern Ireland, particularly concerning the complexities introduced by the Windsor Framework.

Examples of disagreements include:

  1. Jim Allister’s Critique: Jim Allister (North Antrim) (TUV) challenges the Secretary of State, questioning the applicability of UK tariffs in Northern Ireland due to the EU’s customs code. He points out the disadvantage faced by Northern Ireland compared to Great Britain in terms of tariffs on imports, specifically questioning the feasibility of the reimbursement scheme. This criticism indicates a significant disagreement with the approach taken by the Government regarding Northern Ireland’s situation.

  2. Greg Smith’s Comments: Greg Smith (Mid Buckinghamshire) (Con) expresses dissatisfaction with the lack of detail on the trade agreement’s impact on Northern Ireland. He questions the practical implications of the preferential rates and the protection of Northern Ireland’s special status, indicating a lack of clarity and suggesting ongoing concern over the complexity of the situation.

  3. Sammy Wilson’s Concerns: Sammy Wilson (East Antrim) (DUP) directly states that the Secretary of State evaded the question about the impact on Northern Ireland. He criticizes the complexity and time-consuming nature of the duty reimbursement process, highlighting the practical difficulties faced by businesses in Northern Ireland.

Despite these points of contention, the overall tone remains relatively cordial, and there are efforts from the Secretary of State, Jonathan Reynolds, to address these concerns in detail and with promises to work collaboratively. This indicates a moderate level of disagreement, where criticisms are noted but there’s an attempt to resolve or mitigate them through dialogue and promised action.