🚆 Railway Services: South-West

Westminster Hall

🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️ 🌶️

The parliamentary session focused on the urgent need for improvements in railway services in the South-West of England, highlighting issues like unreliable services, high fares, and inadequate infrastructure. MPs from various constituencies expressed frustration over the economic impact of railway disruptions, particularly citing the 2014 Dawlish storm incident which cost the local economy £1.2 billion. The debate also addressed the looming disruptions from the HS2 project at Old Oak Common, which could add significant delays to journeys from the South-West to London. The Transport Minister responded by acknowledging the issues and promising continued investment and efforts to minimize future disruptions, though specific commitments on funding were not immediately forthcoming.

Summary

  • The south-west of England heavily depends on its railway network, which is essential for the local economy. The MP for Newton Abbot highlighted the importance of the railway, especially given the region’s limited road infrastructure.

  • The 2014 storms in Dawlish caused significant damage to the mainline railway, resulting in an eight-week closure and an economic loss of £1.2 billion. Since then, four phases of a resilience program have been completed to improve the railway’s reliability.

  • The debate emphasized ongoing concerns about the railway’s vulnerability, particularly the need for funding the fifth phase of the Dawlish resilience program to prevent future disruptions due to landslips.

  • Accessibility at railway stations was a key issue, with MPs calling for improvements through the Access for All program to support disabled passengers and enhance station accessibility.

  • The construction of the HS2 link and the Old Oak Common station will impact south-west rail services, potentially adding significant time to journeys. There is concern about the consultation and the economic effects of these changes on the region.

  • MPs expressed frustration over poor punctuality, frequent cancellations, and high fares on regional services, which are vital for daily commuters and the local economy.

  • There were calls for more local services, additional train carriages, reliable Wi-Fi, and electrification of parts of the line to reduce journey times, particularly in Cornwall.

  • The debate included discussions on the potential benefits of public ownership of railways, with some MPs advocating for renationalisation to improve service reliability and affordability.

  • The Transport Minister acknowledged the importance of the railway to the south-west, confirming efforts to increase capacity and improve performance. He highlighted ongoing work to develop the railway network and address the concerns raised.

  • The government is reviewing its transport infrastructure plans to ensure they drive economic growth and provide value for taxpayers, amid calls for greater investment in the south-west’s rail services.

Divisiveness

The session on ‘Railway Services: South-West’ displays minimal disagreement. The MPs unanimously raise concerns and call for improvements in the region’s railway services, indicating a consensus on the need for better railway infrastructure and services. The interventions are supportive, with MPs reinforcing each other’s points about accessibility, service reliability, and the impact of ongoing projects like HS2 on their constituents. The Minister’s response acknowledges these concerns and offers reassurances and updates on various initiatives, which are generally received positively by the MPs. The absence of overt conflict or opposition to the points raised further supports the rating of 1 for disagreement.